| 2023 | Baldur’s Gate 3 / 96 | Baldur’s Gate 3 / 96 | 62.5% | Tears of the Kingdom / 96 |
| 2022 | Elden Ring / 96 | Elden Ring / 96 | 72.6% | God of War Ragnarok / 94 |
| 2021 | Forza Horizon 5 / 92 | It Takes Two / 88 | 19.9% | |
| 2020 | Persona 5 Royal / 95 | The Last of Us Part II / 93 | 49.7% | Hades / 93 |
| 2019 | Disco Elysium / 91 | Sekiro / 90 | 18.1% | Resident Evil 2 Remake / 91 |
| 2018 | Red Dead Redemption 2 / 97 | God of War / 94 | 50.8% | |
| 2017 | Breath of the Wild / 97 | Breath of the Wild / 97 | 57% | Super Mario Odyssey / 97 |
| 2016 | Uncharted 4 / 93 | Overwatch / 91 | 23.9% | |
| 2015 | Metal Gear Solid V / 93 | The Witcher 3 / 92 | 58.7% | Bloodborne / 92 |
| 2014 | Super Smash Bros. / 92 | Dragon Age: Inquisition / 85 | 31.7% | |
| 2013 | Grand Theft Auto V / 97 | Grand Theft Auto V / 97 | 30.1% | The Last of Us / 95 |
| 2012 | Persona 4 Golden / 93 | The Walking Dead / 91 | | |
| 2011 | The Elder Scrolls V / 96 | The Elder Scrolls V / 96 | | Portal 2 / 95 |
| 2010 | Super Mario Galaxy 2 / 97 | Red Dead Redemption / 95 | | Mass Effect 2 / 96 |
| 2009 | Uncharted 2 / 96 | Uncharted 2 / 96 | | |
| 2008 | Grand Theft Auto IV / 98 | Grand Theft Auto IV / 98 | | |
| 2007 | Super Mario Galaxy / 97 | BioShock / 96 | | |
| 2006 | Twilight Princess / 95 | The Elder Scrolls IV / 94 | | |
| 2005 | Resident Evil 4 / 96 | Resident Evil 4 / 96 | | |
| 2004 | Half-Life 2 / 96 | GTA: San Andreas / 95 | | |
| 2003 | The Wind Waker / 96 | Madden NFL 2004 / 94 | | |
| 2002 | Metroid Prime / 97 | | | GTA: Vice City / 95 |
| 2001 | Pro Skater 3 / 97 | | | Grand Theft Auto III / 97 |
| 2000 | Perfect Dark / 97 | | | |
